One serious question at a time.
EP 7

Navigating Identity Choices: Free Will, Society, and the Comedy Spectrum

Recorded January 5, 202315:122,012 words

Between the TripsMen, Women and Relationships

Transcript

Each time opens that moment of the video on YouTube in a new tab, so this page stays open. Machine transcript from the recording: accurate on ordinary speech, less reliable on names and unusual terms.

0:00:01

Man, I was just thinking today, and I wanted to record something.

0:00:07

Alright, so it all started, I was watching Bobby Lee comic clips, and thinking, he really

0:00:21

is an artist of his craft.

0:00:24

Whereas, similar to like, Norm Macdonald, I would guess Theo Vaughn, Andy Kaufman was really open about it.

0:00:38

Like, people kind of knew that he's playing a character.

0:00:46

And I guess what Andy Kaufman's doing is pushing the limit because he's playing such a wacky character.

0:00:54

And then writing that line between you like, is that really him?

0:00:58

It's too wacky of a character.

0:00:59

And then you know it's a character, but he hasn't gone quite far enough yet that you can't tell.

0:01:10

And that doubt is the line, the fun, the comedy he was doing.

0:01:16

So Norm was really good because he walked that line back.

0:01:22

An absurdity.

0:01:24

And so when you listen to Norm Macdonald, I mean, maybe he's not playing a character.

0:01:30

To me, he's playing a character, and that's the genius of it.

0:01:36

Similar in the movie, The Prestige, where the magician is doing this trick that no one can figure out.

0:01:44

And come to find out, he's not really an old man, so that's why he has the body strength to hold this goldfish tank in between his knees with this big long thing.

0:01:54

Because when he leaves the theater and enters the theater, the only time that people see him, he's playing an old man.

0:01:59

So the trick is done offstage.

0:02:03

So, like, Dice Clay's playing a character.

0:02:10

And he played it, and everybody knew it was a character.

0:02:13

He knew it was a character.

0:02:15

But then he played it for so damn long that he became the character.

0:02:18

So now I think he lost himself in the character in real life.

0:02:21

And no one thinks that it's weird.

0:02:25

I would say...

0:02:30

There's a lot of people like that.

0:02:33

So then I was thinking as a society and I was like, if we were to take that and flip it over to what socialism is, just shallowness, like social, whatever it gets, whatever the social

0:02:47

construct is, reality doesn't matter.

0:02:50

Because we can all just kind of like play along and perceive things how we perceive things, you know.

0:02:59

So, like, we know within reality that things are made of elements, nitrogen, carbon, oxygen, hydrogen, blah, blah, blah.

0:03:09

But in an everyday thing, you don't think about it.

0:03:11

You just think about the shallowness of your flesh and your skin, and you take for granted that there's oxygen, which is nitrogen at the perfect level that you can breathe it in, you survive and grow and pass on offspring and stuff.

0:03:25

So now I'm just thinking, like, if...

0:03:30

Socialism is a lot of fun if you look at it like the theater.

0:03:35

Life is but a stage and all the people merely players.

0:03:41

And you take Dylan Mulaney, who's day one of being a girl, day whatever.

0:03:54

I'm just wondering if he believes it, or wants to believe it.

0:04:08

He makes the change.

0:04:11

Then he wants society to accept the change, and if everybody plays along, then the reality of the situation, it is what it is.

0:04:21

Meaning, like, they're trying to change the perception as if let's all play make-believe together, but

0:04:36

let's play it at such a high level of creativity that it's no longer that, but reality.

0:04:47

The only way I could explain it to somebody logical that's probably flipping out right now, like, no, there is a reality behind this and stuff.

0:04:54

So it is similar to the matrix, whereas we're all just elements and stuff.

0:05:01

And if you think of the binary green zeros and ones as like the element of the truth and the structure and the fabric of the universe, then what we perceive as what we have here is the reality.

0:05:13

It's like a layer on top of that on a layer and a layer.

0:05:21

But at some point it's like if enough people that people surround themselves within that bubble start reflecting back their perception, even if it is a chosen perception of

0:05:35

free will.

0:05:37

So I don't understand what the argument for born that way or not.

0:05:43

So the argument to born that way is, I guess, an appeal to the people of reality.

0:05:50

And it's funny because the people of reality, similar to myself, are also a lot of times a free will advocate.

0:05:59

Although Sam Harris's are more of a, I don't even want to get into this, deterministic.

0:06:07

But if you can choose who you are, and you really do choose, and the people that are around you can also choose to perceive you as that choice, then they're saying like, you can create your own world if everybody just...

0:06:24

The problem is, and I kind of get this too on the other side, is if I have free will and I don't want to choose that, then why don't I?

0:06:33

And they're saying, well, you're ruining my life.

0:06:35

Like I'm trying to play this game, so just play along with me.

0:06:38

And they're saying, no, I won't play this game.

0:06:39

I like to live in this world where even though you're using markers that are trying to trigger parts of my biological brain to have a particular reaction.

0:06:51

I can intercept that with my free will and understand what the reality of the situation is.

0:06:59

I can see it both ways.

0:07:01

I mean, I guess everybody is playing within those two realms on some spectrum.

0:07:12

And I guess that's the joke with autism, is some people that are autistic see everything on the high end creative side, where they can't tell the difference between reality and...

0:07:25

Perception, and then people on the other side can only see things so black and white of reality that they don't understand the nuance.

0:07:37

But it's really interesting when you look at, for me at least, the reflective from the art side of it.

0:07:51

Within the realm of Hollywood, it's acceptable for Bobby Lee to kind of play that character.

0:07:57

For Theo Vaughn, for...

0:08:29

So why is it okay for Eddie, you know, Eddie Lizard was never really attacked within comedy because he was within Hollywood, but Dylan Mulaney

0:08:43

is doing a similar thing and people are treating it like it's outside Hollywood, but really Hollywood doesn't have the control on it anymore.

0:08:53

He's got a TikTok account or she's got a TikTok account.

0:09:02

It's a decentralized way to play that character to the extreme and then also say what's the big deal.

0:09:13

Bobby Lee's playing a character, Norm MacDonald's playing a character, Dice Clay's playing a character, Dylan Mullaney's playing a character.

0:09:22

And to an extent, Will Smith is playing a character.

0:09:26

That's why he got in so much trouble when he smacked Chris Rock.

0:09:32

It's because the character that he was playing was supposed to be this guy that's got it all figured out, cool, calm, and collective, and he's moving with the times and the stuff, and then he gets angry because he's not that woke.

0:09:47

You know what I mean?

0:09:47

The underlying thing about the baldness was not the alopecia.

0:09:54

It was he couldn't make the jokes that everybody knew he wanted to make, so any joke...

0:10:05

About that is a joke about Will Smith's wife being in charge and cheating on him.

0:10:14

So it's either don't make a joke, or if you don't make a joke, then everybody knows you only make that joke because everybody knows the big elephant in the room.

0:10:22

Big elephant we're not talking about in the room right now.

0:10:24

Because they're trying to pretend something right now, the Oscars.

0:10:29

And then behind the scenes it's completely different.

0:10:33

I think politicians do this really well.

0:10:36

And that's why they say, You know, Congress is for ugly people, basically.

0:10:42

It's Hollywood for ugly people.

0:10:45

I mean, the media tried to destroy Trump in that sense, to the people that are on the right that are kind of reality-based.

0:10:57

When they see Melania and Trump getting in a little argument and slap hands, and the left's like, see?

0:11:02

Blah, blah, she hates him or whatever.

0:11:04

People on the right, like I've been married for 20 years, like that happens in a marriage, you don't end everything, like they're, you know, they're real people and they got in an argument and they're not fake on camera and blah blah blah, and they see an authentic

0:11:18

truth to it if they're in relationships.

0:11:21

And then, similar to Bill Clinton and Hillary Clinton, so...

0:11:30

When they're married, he gets caught doing stuff sexually.

0:11:33

She stands by him.

0:11:34

He gets caught doing other stuff.

0:11:36

He's on an airplane going to Epstein Island.

0:11:38

So they played their role very well as far as their goal was probably not a marriage but a business arrangement, which is fine.

0:11:49

But, you know, I'm sure they had some arguments and there was some sadness or whatever behind the scenes.

0:11:56

And it never really came out in person.

0:11:58

They both did a really good job of playing.

0:12:02

That public role of being a cold couple.

0:12:07

It's not like they were holding hands and making out or whatever, but they were just together, they dressed up, they went to these things, they clapped for one another, they did what needed to be done.

0:12:16

And the perception, at least, even though the marriage might seem cold, is that they stuck it out.

0:12:22

But I mean, behind the scenes they could have been also hiding and sleeping in different rooms and trying to kill one another or like...

0:12:31

Who knows, screaming and yelling, you know, it's really interesting when you think about it.

0:12:38

So that's why I was now also thinking about when people turn on TikTok and Instagram reels and stuff and they enjoy that or they enjoy something, the stuff

0:12:52

that goes viral is normally...

0:12:56

Very authentic or something that happens out of the norm.

0:12:59

It's very rarely that scripted stuff goes viral, in which case if it does, it could either be pushed out algorithmically on purpose, but

0:13:15

sometimes it's also like an FU.

0:13:17

And one of the things I'm thinking about is like when Shane Gillis got kicked off of SNL, which is obviously a setup, like they could have.

0:13:26

Picked so many things that he said over the years.

0:13:29

They picked the Asian comment because there was an Asian gay man going for the spot.

0:13:32

So I think the whole thing was a setup from the start.

0:13:36

But when Gillis and Reeves took off, Gillis and whatever it is, his skits comedy, the stuff kind of went viral as a FU to the fact that he wasn't on SNL and the skits were good.

0:13:51

So that's a time that I can think of where a very well thought out stuff goes viral.

0:13:59

So, the people that have stuff out in that video, like, and are making content, I think they have a particular niche that they're good at.

0:14:12

And it's, you know, they call it a brand, really demarking the way that you are.

0:14:17

But that's, you know, the Kardashians do it well.

0:14:19

The house is clean, blah, blah, blah, we don't argue, and da, da, da.

0:14:22

But in real life, it's like, you can actually see the carnage of divorce and separation and all that stuff, drug addicts dying and stuff.

0:14:38

I don't know, it's just really interesting that we have the decentralized ability now to make authentic videos.

0:14:44

I can just put a camera up to my face and instead of having to have background lighting and all this fancy stuff, I can just have my no breather in, no shirt on, about to go to bed with my eye things on.

0:14:59

I don't know if I would have the balls to post this, but I think I said some very provocative things that need to be thought about, so I don't know.

0:15:09

I'm going to start raking the podcast.

All episodesSearchSupportDonate